Attorney Paul Shaw Comments on Reviewer Confidentiality in Science Magazine Article

January 31, 2018 Media Mentions

Verrill Dana attorney Paul Shaw was quoted in an online article featured in the publicationScienceentitled "In Unusual Move, Judge Grants CrossFit's Request to Unmask Anonymous Peer Reviewers." The article discusses a legal dispute between the branded fitness regimen company, CrossFit, and the National Strength and Conditioning Association (NSCA). The plaintiff, CrossFit, alleged that the injury statistic cited in a 2013 paper that appeared in The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research was intentionally skewed by the journal's publisher, NSCA, a competitor in the fitness business.

As a result, a state judge in California is now forcing the journal publisher to breach its confidentiality policy and identity the article's anonymous peer reviewers.

Paul Shaw, who has represented The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) for 17 years, commented on his experience fielding subpoenas requesting information about peer-reviewed articles, "Invariably, one of the requests will be for the identity of and memoranda done by the peer reviewers."

Read "In Unusual Move, Judge Grants CrossFit's Request to Unmask Anonymous Peer Reviewers" on

Firm Highlights


Elections and Constitutional Law: Successfully Challenged Certification of Initiative Petition

In a victory for consumers and the ride-hailing public, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court recently barred the Secretary of State from placing on the November ballot initiative petitions proposed by companies such as Uber...


The PHE is Ending: Do You Know Where Your Waivers Are?

While the pandemic is not over, the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) is expected to expire soon, which means that a number of operational, safety, and billing standards that were waived at the beginning...


2021 Medicare Cost Report Preparation, Reminders and New Developments for Hospitals


Patent Litigation: Mesenchymal Stem Cells

Represented small biotech company and two academic researchers against large pharmaceutical company in dispute over inventorship of several patents relating to mesenchymal stem cells and their uses, as well as defending against numerous state...


Hospitals Win 340B Medicare Rate Cut Suit, But When, How, and How Much They Will Recoup Remains Unclear

In a recent unanimous decision, the Supreme Court found that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”), part of the federal Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”), erred when it significantly reduced...


77 Verrill Attorneys Recognized by Best Lawyers® 2023, Including Six Named Lawyers of the Year


Seven Verrill Attorneys named to Boston Magazine’s Top Lawyers of 2022 List

(December 8, 2022) Verrill attorneys Ruth A. Mattson , Michael L. Fay , David M. Friedman , Regina M. Hurley , Kyle T. MacDonald , Kristin S. Doeberl and Brian M. Hurley were recently...


Verrill Welcomes Back Attorney Stephen B. Segal to Firm’s Litigation & Trial Group


New DOJ Task Force Announced Will Impact Health Care Providers & Prescribers in Northern New England

Major enforcement news was released today, Wednesday, June 29, 2022, for medical professionals and anyone working in or around the health care space in Maine , New Hampshire , and Vermont . The United...


Patent Litigation: Semiconductors

Represented semiconductor manufacturer in patent case against competitor in litigation in U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, in which both sides asserted patents relating to power management and A-D converters; conducted Markman...

Contact Verrill at (855) 307 0700