You Might Be a Winner
        A blog from the attorneys of Verrill

        Time to Take Your Shot: Prize Indemnity Insurance Edition

        by Robert Laplaca on November 2, 2017

        We’re getting into the swing of the basketball and hockey seasons and you know what that means? (Yes, the Knicks still haven’t been mathematically eliminated.) But also, it’s time for the Half-Court Shot Contests and Blue Line Shot Contests to give weekend warriors the chance to quit their day job.

        Prizes can range from a few hundred dollars to a few hundred thousand dollars. All you need to do is shoot a 9.55 inch diameter ball a distance of 94 feet into an 18 inch diameter hole. Or, shoot a 3-inch puck a distance of 90 feet into a hole about 4 inches wide – while standing on ice. If you’re not Meadowlark Lemon, your odds of making the half-court shot are about 1 in 50. And the odds of scoring on that one-timer are much higher, even if you’re Wayne Gretzky.

        Because lightening always strikes, there is Prize Indemnity Insurance. You don’t need to break the bank just because some hotshot broke the odds.

        How Does It Work?

        The Sponsor purchases prize indemnity insurance from a reputable insurer. The insurer will assess the “risks” of a contestant winning and issue a policy for a premium. If the shot is made, the insurer pays out.

        How Much Does It Cost?

        Policies may vary between 2% of the prize to as high as 20%, with, for example, premiums usually between 3 to 15 percent for a half-court basketball shot contest. The premium depends upon a number of factors, most importantly, the odds and the amount of the prize.

        How To Keep Premiums Down

        Include restrictions that make it less likely for little Mario Lemieux to light the lamp. Such as:

        • Restrict entry to people who’ve never played professional, semi-pro, college, or high school basketball/hockey. (Or at least haven’t played in high school for a number of years – we all get rusty.)
        • No warmups – one shot, do or die.
        • Pick the winner at the event (if possible). We’ve all heard stories of winners who found out months ahead of time that they’ll be taking the winning shot, who then thought it wise to repeatedly practice half-court shots until the big day.
        • Make the winner take the shot at half-time, on television, with family/friends/players present – anything to increase the pressure (I mean, make it more realistic).
        • Make sure the person taking the shot is the person you selected. This seems obvious but a few years ago, 11-year old Nate Smith made a miracle hockey shot for a $50,000 prize, but unfortunately, the person selected to shoot was his twin brother!
        • Include any other restrictions or conditions that the insurer requires for payout of the policy.
        • Put all restrictions and conditions in the Official Rules and validate that the potential winner meets all of the requirements. Earlier this year a University of Louisville student stuck a half-court shot during halftime of a women’s basketball game only to learn that he wouldn’t win the $38,000 prize because the rules prohibited former high school basketball players. It was later reported that the University (who sponsored the event) decided to give the “lucky” student a consolation package of books and his meal plan for two years.

        Finally, I give you an odd prize indemnity insurance practice in Japan. Not only must a sponsor be armed with prize indemnity insurance for those hole-in-one contests, but Japanese golfers also need to make sure they can cover the high costs of making a hole-in-one. Every one of the estimated 1 in 12,000 who hits a hole-in-one in Japan has the honor of holding and paying for a party in his or her honor – apparently a party on the scale of a mini-wedding – along with souvenirs for the guests, a commemorative tree planting and a donation to the golf course.

        To the contestants: if young Nate Smith can put the biscuit in the basket from 90 feet away (see video here), there’s hope for all of us.

        To the sponsors: if young Nate Smith can hit the five-hole from 90 feet away (see video above), you better be prepared to pay the consequences.

        You Might Be a Winner

        Promotion and sweepstakes laws vary widely across the fifty states and under federal regulations, creating complex challenges for today’s innovative marketers. This blog explores the latest updates and trends in promotion and marketing law, offering practical insights to help brands stay compliant while pushing creative boundaries. We’ll also discuss noteworthy, questionable, and groundbreaking promotional campaigns to encourage thoughtful discussion among marketing and legal professionals.

        Key Contacts

        Subscribe

        Looking for more great content? Subscribe for regular legal updates and information delivered right to your inbox.

        Firm Highlights

        Blog

        What is a Bonus for Purposes of ERISA?

        An ongoing dispute about a Department of Labor advisory opinion published last September raises a basic but unanswered question under the ERISA: What...
        Media Mentions

        Verrill Recognized by WMTW for Partnership Supporting Hunger Relief in Maine

        Verrill was recently featured in coverage by WMTW News 8 for its role in a collaborative effort to combat food insecurity across southern...
        Press Releases

        33 Verrill Attorneys, Across Four Offices, Recognized in the 2026 Chambers USA Guide

        BOSTON, Massachusetts, PORTLAND, Maine, WESTPORT, Connecticut, and WASHINGTON, D.C. – Verrill has been recognized as a Leading Firm in 14...
        Blog

        Will the Knicks Beat the Spurs? (Are Prediction Market Event Contracts Gambling?)

        For those of you who like to keep score, currently 18 states are engaged in litigation over prediction markets, such as Kalshi and Polymarket,...
        Alerts and Newsletters

        DOJ Announces Faster Review and Enhanced Enforcement for Benefits-Fraud FCA Matters

        On May 27, 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Civil Division issued a new memorandum, “Accelerating Review and Enhancing Enforcement in...
        Alerts and Newsletters

        DOJ Announces Minnesota Health Care Fraud Takedown; Signals Intensified Medicaid Enforcement Nationwide

        On May 21, the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) announced a first-of-its kind Minnesota Health Care Fraud Takedown charging 15 defendants, including...
        Media Mentions

        Lauren Galvin Quoted in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly on Arbitration and Anti-SLAPP Protections

        Verrill Partner Lauren Galvin was recently featured in a Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly article highlighting a notable Superior Court decision...
        Blog

        Section 530A Accounts: What Employers Should Consider Before Offering Contributions to “Trump” Accounts

        Section 530A accounts, commonly referred to as Trump accounts, have attracted attention since the enactment of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in...
        Blog

        Navigating PBM Reform: Regulatory Changes, Market Shifts, and Practical Guidance for ERISA Fiduciaries

        Pharmacy Benefit Manager (“PBM”) arrangements have long relied on rebates with limited transparency into true drug costs. Recent regulatory and...
        Blog

        DOL’s Proposed Regulation on Selecting Alternative Investments: Broad Implications for 401(k) and 403(b) Plan Fiduciaries

        On March 30, 2026, the Department of Labor issued a proposed regulation purporting to implement an executive order to expand access to “alternative...
        Press Releases

        Verrill Welcomes Private Clients & Fiduciary Services Attorney Gracie Castle

        BOSTON, Massachusetts – Verrill is pleased to welcome Gracie Castle to the firm’s Private Clients & Fiduciary Services Group as an Associate,...
        Published Works

        Francesco De Vito Authors Article in the Journal of the American College of Mortgage Attorneys

        Verrill Partner Frank De Vito authored an article featured in the Spring 2026 issue of The Abstract, the journal of the American College of Mortgage...